Quick answer (TLDR): On November 9, 2026, Icewing is worth 15 on MM2 Values and 13 on Supreme Values. It is the cheapest Ancient in Murder Mystery 2, ranked 16th of 16 Ancients and 283rd of 1,035 priced items on MM2 Values, with demand 2/10 and a Stable tag. 77 of the 128 Godlies on the same list are worth more. Icewing was sold as a 2,499 Robux gamepass in the Christmas Event 2018, then mass-duped twice, which is why the value collapsed. It is trade-only now. Values are community estimates, not official prices.
Icewing looks like a top-tier item. It is an Ancient, it is a big ice scythe, and it came from a limited Christmas pack. That is exactly why so many players overvalue it in trades. This guide gives you the real number from both value lists, explains why it sits at the bottom of the Ancient tier, and shows trades that come out even.
All values were pulled on November 9, 2026, around 13:30 UTC from MM2 Values (mm2values.com, list last updated November 6, 2026) and Supreme Values (read through the mm2values.app item page, because supremevalues.com sits behind a bot check). Release and glitch history comes from the Murder Mystery 2 Wiki. This applies to the current MM2 build during the Halloween Event 2026, which ends on November 16, 2026. MM2 had 430,710 players online at the time of the pull, according to the Roblox Games API.
Not keen on the grind? Timesaver runs a Blox Fruits boosting service that covers fruits, awakenings and race progress on your own account.
Roblox - Blox Fruits Boost
Get any fruit, awakened and ready
How much is Icewing worth in MM2?
Icewing is worth 15 on MM2 Values and 13 on Supreme Values. The two lists sit about 13% apart, and Supreme is the lower one.
| Item | Tier | MM2 Values | Supreme Values | Demand (MM2V) | Rarity (MM2V) | Trend |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Icewing | Ancient knife | 15 | 13 | 2/10 | 1 | Stable |
Three numbers matter more than the headline value:
- Supreme cut Icewing by 2 on its last run, from 15 to 13 (a 13.3% drop). MM2 Values has kept it at 15 at every snapshot since September 26, 2026.
- Supreme rates demand at 1/10, against 2/10 on MM2 Values. Both lists agree that few traders want it.
- Its rarity score is 1, the lowest of any Ancient. There are a lot of Icewings in circulation, and the next section explains why.
The MM2 Wiki infobox shows the same pair of figures: 15 on MM2 Values and 13 on Supreme.
Why is Icewing worth so little for an Ancient?
Most Ancients are hard to get. You grind an event battle pass, then pay tens of thousands of event tokens for the final reward. Icewing skipped all of that. It was the only item in the Icewing Gamepass, which MM2 creator Nikilis sold for 2,499 Robux during the Christmas Event 2018 (December 23, 2018 to January 14, 2019), per the Icewing Gamepass wiki page. Anyone with the Robux could buy one on day one.
Then it got duped, twice:
- The Icewing Glitch (2018 to 2019). A few buyers found a way to duplicate the gamepass item. The wiki page on the glitch says Nikilis "found out almost right away and removed the game pass", and the buyers involved were banned. Some of those glitched Icewings still exist.
- The Duping Glitch (2022). This one was far bigger. Players found that owning (or borrowing) the gamepass let them copy the shop item in huge stacks, and Icewing was the main target. Nikilis deleted most of the large duplicated stacks on October 16, 2022, but the damage to the price was done.
The screenshot above, kept on the Duping Glitch (2022) wiki page, shows one inventory holding 13,940 Icewings. In the wiki's own words, Icewing "has lost a ton of value due to being heavily targeted," and after 2022 it "reached an all time low in value."
So the label says Ancient, but the supply looks more like a common Godly. Value lists price items on supply and demand, not on tier names.
Where does Icewing rank among MM2 Ancients?
Dead last. Here is the full Ancient tier on MM2 Values, pulled the same afternoon:
| Rank | Ancient | MM2 Values | Demand | Trend |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Nik's Scythe | 250,000,000 | 11 | Overpaid for |
| 2 | Gingerscope | 16,000 | 5 | Stable |
| 3 | Traveler's Axe | 7,150 | 5 | Underpaid for |
| 4 | Celestial | 1,950 | 4.5 | Stable |
| 5 | Vampire's Axe | 1,425 | 4.5 | Stable |
| 6 | Emberbow | 450 | 5.5 | Fluctuating |
| 7 | Emberscythe | 450 | 5 | Fluctuating |
| 8 | Harvester | 250 | 3 | Stable |
| 9 | Icepiercer | 165 | 2.5 | Stable |
| 10 | Icebreaker | 70 | 2 | Stable |
| 11 | Batwing | 45 | 2 | Stable |
| 12 | Elderwood Scythe | 40 | 1.5 | Stable |
| 13 | Swirly Axe | 40 | 1.5 | Stable |
| 14 | Hallowscythe | 32 | 1.5 | Stable |
| 15 | Log Chopper | 20 | 1.5 | Stable |
| 16 | Icewing | 15 | 2 | Stable |
Skip Nik's Scythe when you compare: it is a gift-only knife that almost never trades. The middle of the Ancient tier sits at 207.5, and Icewing is about 93% below that. Gingerscope, the second-best Ancient, is worth more than 1,000 times as much.
The closest comparison is Batwing, the other gamepass Ancient. It was sold the same way for the same 2,499 Robux during Halloween 2018, and it was also hit by the 2022 dupe. It still trades at 45, three times Icewing. The difference is that Icewing was the main target of the 2022 dupe. The two other ice Ancients, Icebreaker (70) and Icepiercer (165), came from token grinds, not a shop, and it shows in their prices.
Is Icewing worth more than a Godly?
Only some of them. On MM2 Values, 77 of 128 Godlies are worth more than Icewing, and 51 are worth the same or less. Godlies at exactly 15 include Virtual, Slasher, Minty, Luger Cane, Vampire's Edge and Jinglegun.
A few Godlies people often compare it with:
| Godly | MM2 Values | vs Icewing (15) |
|---|---|---|
| Bat | 120 | 8x more |
| Candy | 90 | 6x more |
| Iceblaster | 35 | over 2x more |
| Old Glory | 17 | slightly more |
| Gingerblade | 13 | slightly less |
| Snowflake | 5 | a third of it |
So if a newer player tells you "Ancient beats Godly", that is not how values work in 2026. Check the item, not the tier.
Is Icewing in high demand right now?
Icewing moves a lot, but mostly in one direction: people are trying to get rid of it. MM2 Trade Hub counted posts over the last 30 days, out of 3,890 trades:
| Signal (last 30 days) | Icewing |
|---|---|
| Offered in trades | 137 |
| Asked for in trades | 51 |
| Most-traded rank | #17 of 508 items |
| Median solo asking price | about 38% over value (30 offers) |
The Trade Hub sums it up: "More traders are offering Ice Wing than asking for it, so buyers have the upper hand." Icewing is offered almost three times as often as it is requested.
Owners still ask for a lot. When people put Icewing up, they most often ask for Harvester (11 times), Icepiercer (9) or Bat (6). Those are worth 250, 165 and 120. Asking for a Harvester for an Icewing means asking for about 16 times its value, so those posts rarely get accepted.
On Reddit you will also see the other side of it. Recent r/MurderMystery2 posts asked whether trading a Snowflake for an Icewing was worth it, and one player was buying up an "Icewing stack" in bulk. A Snowflake is worth 5, so getting an Icewing for one is a small win. Buying stacks only makes sense if you are paying under 15 each.
Roblox - Grow a Garden Pets
Get the pet you actually want
What are fair trades for Icewing?
All figures are MM2 Values numbers from November 9, 2026, and each trade lands within a few points of even.
Trading Icewing across or down (you receive items):
| You give | You get | Their total |
|---|---|---|
| Icewing (15) | Virtual or Vampire's Edge (15) | 15 |
| Icewing (15) | 3x Snowflake (5 each) | 15 |
| Icewing (15) | Gingerblade (13) | 13, ask for a small add |
| Icewing (15) | Old Glory (17) | 17, they may ask for a small add |
Trading Icewing up (you add something):
| You give | You get | Your total |
|---|---|---|
| Icewing (15) + Old Glory (17) | Hallowscythe (32) | 32 |
| Icewing (15) + Elderwood Blade (32) | Batwing (45) | 47 |
| Icewing (15) + Elderwood Blade (32) + Hallowgun (22) | Icebreaker (70) | 69 |
| Icewing (15) + Candy (90) + Old Glory (17) | Bat (120) | 122 |
Because buyers have the edge, do not pay more than about 21 (the 38% median ask) for an Icewing, and do not expect more than 15 when you sell one. For anything with three or more items, check our MM2 value list and the full Ancient value list first.
Will Icewing go up in value this Christmas?
Unlikely. The reasons:
- Supply is huge. Even after the October 2022 cleanup, Icewing has the lowest rarity score of any Ancient.
- It cannot come back. The Icewing Gamepass is offsale, and no re-release has been announced.
- New Christmas Ancients pull attention away. Each recent Christmas event added its own top reward: Icepiercer in 2022, Gingerscope in 2023 and Celestial in 2024. Traders chase the new item, not the 2018 one.
- The trend is down, not up. Supreme just cut it from 15 to 13, and demand sits at 1 to 2 out of 10.
The MM2 Christmas 2026 event has not been announced yet. Past events started on December 21, 2022, December 20, 2023, December 20, 2024 and December 14, 2025. If you want an Ancient that holds value, Icewing is the wrong pick. If you just like how it looks, it is the cheapest way to put an Ancient in your loadout.
We will refresh this page monthly, and weekly once Christmas 2026 goes live.
How do you get Icewing in MM2 now?
You cannot buy Icewing in-game anymore. You have two routes:
- Trade for it. Use the tables above. Start at 15 and hold firm, since sellers outnumber buyers almost three to one.
- Buy it from a marketplace. Our MM2 Ancient weapons page lists Icewing next to the other Ancients.
If you are trading up from Icewing, the items owners keep asking for are also listed on their own pages: Harvester and Icepiercer. New to trading? Our guide on how to get Godly weapons in MM2 explains tiers, boxes and how the trade window works, and the rarest knives in MM2 guide covers the other end of the scale.
Want an Ancient without the trade grind? Pick one up directly:
- MM2 Ancient Weapons (includes Icewing) — Ancient knives and guns, fast delivery
- All Murder Mystery 2 items — Godlys, Chromas and Ancients
FAQ
How much is Icewing worth in MM2? On November 9, 2026, Icewing is worth 15 on MM2 Values and 13 on Supreme Values. MM2 Values has kept it at 15 since at least September 26, 2026, and Supreme just lowered it from 15.
Is Icewing an Ancient or a Godly? Icewing is an Ancient knife. It is the lowest-value Ancient in the game, 16th of 16, and many Godlies are worth more.
Why is Icewing so cheap? It was sold as a 2,499 Robux gamepass, so anyone could buy it, and it was mass-duped in the Icewing Glitch (2018 to 2019) and again in the Duping Glitch (2022). One duped inventory alone held 13,940 copies.
Is a Snowflake for an Icewing a good trade? Yes, for the person getting the Icewing. Snowflake is worth 5 on MM2 Values and Icewing is worth 15, so you gain about 10.
Is Icewing worth more than Batwing? No. Batwing is worth 45 on MM2 Values, three times Icewing's 15. Both were 2,499 Robux gamepass Ancients from 2018, but Icewing was the main target of the 2022 Duping Glitch.
Is there a Chroma Icewing? No. The MM2 Wiki has no Chroma Icewing, and neither value list prices one. Anyone selling a "Chroma Icewing" is selling something that does not exist.
